The
trouble with short-term TSP trading
Stocks rallied early but could not hold those gains
and the selling picked up significantly into the close. This
is getting to be routine and getting frustrating. The C-fund
took the hardest hit losing 1.28%. While the small caps of the
S-fund lost 0.86%, and the I-fund actually gained 0.54% but that
included some fair value from Monday's late rally in U.S. stocks.
Before you ask me about fair value, please check out the
I-Fund
thread on the message board. Our I-fund experts are on the
job there 24-7. OK, maybe 21-6.
Looking for a relief rally, I went to a 100% S fund allocation for a
short-term play anticipating some sort of a bounce. As I
mentioned yesterday, I wanted to bail out of stocks once the S&P 500
moved up toward 1490. Tuesday morning stocks opened to the
upside with a bang. The S&P 500 made it over 1488 and then
started to pullback. I figured we got what we wanted and I
sent out an email alert telling you I had decided to back off again
and move into the F-fund. By the close things went terribly
wrong and we were at the mercy of the TSP trading deadline as all we
could do is sit and watch as the 1% early gain turned into a 1%
loss.

The way I figure it, if
you have been in TSP for a while and your account is in the $200K to
$400K range or higher, and I know many of you are there, it cost you
in the area of $4K to $8K or more to sit and watch the market fall
apart all day yesterday.
I am so grateful that the TSP made the change from monthly
transactions to daily transactions back in 2003, but if any of you
have any influence in this area, we need to find out what can be
done to look toward a deadline closer to the 4PM ET market close.
Real-time transactions would be ideal, but I realize that is not
practical for funds. TSP fees are some of the lowest in the
business and I would be willing to pay higher fees for the added
luxury of a late deadline, as I'm sure many of you would as well.
I realize we are not supposed to trade our accounts, but there are
times when you have to be able to act quickly.
OK, enough whining. The S&P closed in an area of support.
I had hoped to sell before the market came back this far but the
afore mentioned complaining tells you why that didn't work out.
The question remains - will this support, and retest of the prior
low - hold?

Chart provided courtesy of
www.decisionpoint.com
I've noticed an interesting observation with moving averages that
I've mentioned a while back but I never really hear anyone else talk
about it. That is, when a faster moving average goes below the
slowing moving average, it is normally considered a warning sign,
even a sell signal. And that may be true looking out a few
weeks, but sometimes the index immediately reverses during the
crossover. That reversal doesn't usually last too long as the
real sell signal comes at the second crossing below the slow moving
average - if there is one. So the first crossover below gives
can give us a short-term buy signal and the second crossover is the
real sell signal. The opposite is true for when stocks are
moving higher and the faster moving average moves above the slower
moving average. I'm not saying that is true every time.
Just a tendency.
There is no real need to show the indicators. We all know that
the market is very oversold no matter where you look. There is
fear in the air, but the feelings are mixed about whether this is a
buying opportunity or a time to step aside and let things play out
to the downside. Buying this type of action has paid off time
and time again during this bull market and it may payoff here as
well. But if it doesn't, how much downside can you take?
I've watched
RevShark from afar for many years in the old AOL message boards
and his approach to these sell-offs is to sit back and watch it play
out. It is not important for him, as someone who trades for
his living, to pick the bottom, but rather to wait until the all is
clear sign before trading again. Of course trading individual
stocks is a different ballgame than managing a TSP account, but it's
not bad advice. Capital preservation is his primary goal.
Trader Fred's
TSP
Trader System remains on a sell signal and still
no upward movement on the strength chart. See what
Trader Fred has to say today on his
system
page.
The EbbChart System
is in the I-fund again today. Where to
tomorrow? Read more the
ebbchart system page.
I am now in the F-fund. As I complained earlier, I made this
moving thinking I was taking with me a 1 to 2% gain in the last two
days. The reason I chose the F-fund over the G-fund was that
the F-fund has been acting well lately, and I knew the G-fund was
paying yesterday and probably won't pay again until next Monday.
The futures are deep in the red as I write this and we could see a
washout in the morning - a capitulation like sell-off that could
trigger a reversal. Of course if that happens the market will
again look to test the lows it makes. If somehow the futures
turnaround and yesterday's low holds, that could be considered a
successful test. It's never easy. I'm still staying
nimble and could make another change at any time based on what is
happening.
That's all for today. I am currently 100% F fund.
See you tomorrow.
Have questions? Visit our
message board
for answers.
Would you like to be on our
email alert list?
We will send you an email when there is a change to our asset allocation
or market outlook. Your email address will never be given out.
Read our
privacy policy.
By signing up you agree to the TSP Talk
Terms of
Service. More details below **.
Are you bullish or bearish?
Join the Weekly
Sentiment Survey.
Like what you're reading?
Tell a Friend
about us.
|