mlk_man
10-05-2005, 08:23 PM
I would be happy with 17 funds as long as they were diversified among different sectors. Over 100 is most likely too much, especially if costs more in maintenance fees. Having only 5 is a differenct matter. Can you imagine if we had an energy fund to invest in this year........
Improved 401(k)? Who can tell?
Fund line-ups are changing. If Time Warner's plan is any indication, the changes may be baffling.
October 5, 2005: 11:40 AM EDT
By Jeanne Sahadi, CNN/Money senior writer
NEW YORK (CNN/Money) – Which would you prefer: a restaurant that offers a select number of well-prepared entrees or a menu with listings that rival the number of words in the dictionary?
Personally, I prefer the first option. Too much choice exhausts me.
So you'd think the move made by Time Warner, my employer, to simplify and reduce my 401(k) investment choices would delight me.
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/advlinks1.gif
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_bar.gif
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/whatsthis.gif (javascript:CNN_openPopup('/services/overture/cl/frameset.exclude.html','620x430','toolbar=no,locat ion=no,directories=no,status=no,menubar=no,scrollb ars=no,resizable=no,width=620,height=430'))
Become a Certified Financial Planner (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg18tSkYK9k7PyMPiIRvydmwBay5yqoZ04T48sS 5BB5iFgUON8brWQ4rF1Se9g6g7Uz%5FOS%5FLFUVYf27o3%5FE Aj8TVSPG%2Db924Wwy51vb%5FshbOFg9Otvy%2Dvqn45JPXwBZ G24b5Hrz6yfeK%2DNMn8694Z1zGnq%2DvVtt82wwObqI4m8gQ8 t9lyEEaQF7aZagsvHKO8NSKQWDNSYhXrSRqwbvdt145uiKGJRJ Sir4mYEvB75ZDNy8%5FGZNZla6OuuxM6VOra%5F2IAIMhHH5KI 6tk%5FImifMlZojaivc1%2DYbhh19K6b9YCTalgIttq%5FYjeS dJNVlqFD%2DC4iHQjP6MhwlExguDPavaReXcTB1jUrOLfoVNYH q7GHvXuqLDDZlMxQMquL0KPQ%2D0TiVn3g1XiKVRrTniA%2E%2 E&yargs=info1.cffp.edu)
Founded in 1972, the college for financial planning created the Certified...
info1.cffp.edu (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg18tSkYK9k7PyMPiIRvydmwBay5yqoZ04T48sS 5BB5iFgUON8brWQ4rF1Se9g6g7Uz%5FOS%5FLFUVYf27o3%5FE Aj8TVSPG%2Db924Wwy51vb%5FshbOFg9Otvy%2Dvqn45JPXwBZ G24b5Hrz6yfeK%2DNMn8694Z1zGnq%2DvVtt82wwObqI4m8gQ8 t9lyEEaQF7aZagsvHKO8NSKQWDNSYhXrSRqwbvdt145uiKGJRJ Sir4mYEvB75ZDNy8%5FGZNZla6OuuxM6VOra%5F2IAIMhHH5KI 6tk%5FImifMlZojaivc1%2DYbhh19K6b9YCTalgIttq%5FYjeS dJNVlqFD%2DC4iHQjP6MhwlExguDPavaReXcTB1jUrOLfoVNYH q7GHvXuqLDDZlMxQMquL0KPQ%2D0TiVn3g1XiKVRrTniA%2E%2 E&yargs=info1.cffp.edu)
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_dotted.gif
CFP?? Certification Course Online from BU (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg139S9YK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLis%5FrsY8xUcg vRssNry9yErk7O7ydypssFLIw8UqFkLLIreNDQ6qlzK7CDE7WB VzQTfb8qN6BotpuYO%2DhWb5GkrEqgrm2ytNbPwtbOTH3O9O%2 DnOvZItC5w0x7ndxWj1nAq6g7laDgnLlPTumBiQ4XuwCFf8VRr 7Z6jMnBKYxYM8ZYftqZki6WdJVByso36ZmpO1FkKyurkWwJ3Fi CJ0J51bifJdsEuLbzmpnrMaDwndtbbESa8%5F1l7xmAiivMi9k 7YkK%2D%2DLpQ5l9wOKz4Y0zfjg4uXJ3s6KuGfNFj7gCfXM3ZE QL0ZkZ6CUFzROCaMVTIeRhI7x30ceY3cb%2D4uGCzA7iABCgxJ ipB7N7mZ5JP9V6ZkGUwSmuPi6fHr%2DJ7Ii5I4QSg2gGL%2Dk1 nifc%2D%2D%2DneK9BV%5FYyKn1WiBTEW5l3uq939BNSep1hUp WRptqRfVrkP37c98mwL73nPh62RqtoZo4QQb76dhzY9x5%2DDJ QB3MOeOa7V%5FLrc%2E&yargs=www.bostonifi.com)
Pass the CFP?? certification exam - enroll in Boston University online program...
www.bostonifi.com (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg139S9YK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLis%5FrsY8xUcg vRssNry9yErk7O7ydypssFLIw8UqFkLLIreNDQ6qlzK7CDE7WB VzQTfb8qN6BotpuYO%2DhWb5GkrEqgrm2ytNbPwtbOTH3O9O%2 DnOvZItC5w0x7ndxWj1nAq6g7laDgnLlPTumBiQ4XuwCFf8VRr 7Z6jMnBKYxYM8ZYftqZki6WdJVByso36ZmpO1FkKyurkWwJ3Fi CJ0J51bifJdsEuLbzmpnrMaDwndtbbESa8%5F1l7xmAiivMi9k 7YkK%2D%2DLpQ5l9wOKz4Y0zfjg4uXJ3s6KuGfNFj7gCfXM3ZE QL0ZkZ6CUFzROCaMVTIeRhI7x30ceY3cb%2D4uGCzA7iABCgxJ ipB7N7mZ5JP9V6ZkGUwSmuPi6fHr%2DJ7Ii5I4QSg2gGL%2Dk1 nifc%2D%2D%2DneK9BV%5FYyKn1WiBTEW5l3uq939BNSep1hUp WRptqRfVrkP37c98mwL73nPh62RqtoZo4QQb76dhzY9x5%2DDJ QB3MOeOa7V%5FLrc%2E&yargs=www.bostonifi.com)
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_dotted.gif
Financial Advisors: Acquire New Clients (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg19hS4IK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLitrtsZ4sXsU%5 FRpYBsmw%2DDr1gYfCez5BtTpg4vxiDwPeV%5FLFHVYf2mfyNF w2JQVSJEfW9pfjJzvk%2DNa2gKNBOgLZYwe3s75AcZSu6V16CC or9k%2D%5FIJNX9PHZP%2DYsVjkjIv6I2jfiKtO4XZrusq1V8% 2DCrWJ54FGZMa5ZWefJcJGoJqftmf4CWRdJ01z95j056pPzZOY BeSv2gLrFyEJSY94qPOdYkAsaO148%2DbZLGiyJBIOBXNq6oi5 U3DizrEn9M2YmrU0O0Izg1dGvfsIGaM1lV66ric9ZLWKNx9uS6 mS9LYEHDhJ094flMRA%2DGtYgCcKDJivHHaLMsTN5zss3fvSd7 SRH5IMRdJq8X2aZhd7g7ejGspBiOpBoXlgB18b7Mtik%2DnrmG ny30%2E&yargs=www.wiseradvisor.com)
(U.S. only.) WiserAdvisor.com lead generation service, for retirement/estate...
www.wiseradvisor.com (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg19hS4IK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLitrtsZ4sXsU%5 FRpYBsmw%2DDr1gYfCez5BtTpg4vxiDwPeV%5FLFHVYf2mfyNF w2JQVSJEfW9pfjJzvk%2DNa2gKNBOgLZYwe3s75AcZSu6V16CC or9k%2D%5FIJNX9PHZP%2DYsVjkjIv6I2jfiKtO4XZrusq1V8% 2DCrWJ54FGZMa5ZWefJcJGoJqftmf4CWRdJ01z95j056pPzZOY BeSv2gLrFyEJSY94qPOdYkAsaO148%2DbZLGiyJBIOBXNq6oi5 U3DizrEn9M2YmrU0O0Izg1dGvfsIGaM1lV66ric9ZLWKNx9uS6 mS9LYEHDhJ094flMRA%2DGtYgCcKDJivHHaLMsTN5zss3fvSd7 SRH5IMRdJq8X2aZhd7g7ejGspBiOpBoXlgB18b7Mtik%2DnrmG ny30%2E&yargs=www.wiseradvisor.com)
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_dotted.gif
Kiplinger Wealth Management Directory (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg1wtSiIK9k7PyMPiIRvydmQdMyMTqpZ4sEcUgX YANtC0vGL1hPfychMobGK4ht12FtKaB%5F9MSLfL5jfmMRlH1E BrORqGn7ry7icl4Y7qjX5IYwvF%5Fk%5F%5Fq6tkIaT1CJyzkb 4Gzne%5FMNoeAS3NM%5F4sGxRue9fJu143PsepvYsuq3yB6jy% 5FSIplymdQtl56afZcMSrJDDIHanieScZxFzdV9leilKGNHeWn xvBs6kVvxLTkJoNq%2De4sKz7f3jduoWoekwYxTaxSjxEVi6Bj lynmZyP9nNGzB%2Dr5YhgJ9P6aKZDnYiwxavuycgfHSL9VrqHT WCc%5FURS6jKFQoLRsuDOLkbwCcYThqu0vTY8MfL5jwqXrvXKH GUXF5PAZD%2DZDNWMsH4xPP0DNsFWefR4ORtSxLJII%2Dk1699 iOLqBMn4bRop6KZeZMK79DK9heLChwB%5FEDosMzyBODO%5FBB DsnYmusFOD%2DRjpNwP8GoY%5FiuA1tL6lw%2E%2E&yargs=ki plinger.directorym.com)
Evaluate and contact respected wealth management certified financial planners,...
kiplinger.directorym.com (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg1wtSiIK9k7PyMPiIRvydmQdMyMTqpZ4sEcUgX YANtC0vGL1hPfychMobGK4ht12FtKaB%5F9MSLfL5jfmMRlH1E BrORqGn7ry7icl4Y7qjX5IYwvF%5Fk%5F%5Fq6tkIaT1CJyzkb 4Gzne%5FMNoeAS3NM%5F4sGxRue9fJu143PsepvYsuq3yB6jy% 5FSIplymdQtl56afZcMSrJDDIHanieScZxFzdV9leilKGNHeWn xvBs6kVvxLTkJoNq%2De4sKz7f3jduoWoekwYxTaxSjxEVi6Bj lynmZyP9nNGzB%2Dr5YhgJ9P6aKZDnYiwxavuycgfHSL9VrqHT WCc%5FURS6jKFQoLRsuDOLkbwCcYThqu0vTY8MfL5jwqXrvXKH GUXF5PAZD%2DZDNWMsH4xPP0DNsFWefR4ORtSxLJII%2Dk1699 iOLqBMn4bRop6KZeZMK79DK9heLChwB%5FEDosMzyBODO%5FBB DsnYmusFOD%2DRjpNwP8GoY%5FiuA1tL6lw%2E%2E&yargs=ki plinger.directorym.com)
if(cnnEnableCL){if(location.hostname.indexOf('.cnn .com')==-1){cnnAddCSI('contextualLinks','/.element/ssi/contextual/story.html','origin=money&site=cnn_moneveryday_dyn_ctxt&category=moneyeveryday&url=http://robots.cnnfn.com/2005/10/05/commentary/everyday/sahadi/index.htm');}else{cnnAddCSI('contextualLinks','htt p://cl.cnn.com/ctxtlink/jsp/money-story.jsp','origin=money&site=cnn_moneveryday_dyn_ctxt&category=moneyeveryday&url=http://robots.cnnfn.com/2005/10/05/commentary/everyday/sahadi/index.htm');}}
It might, except I've had the hardest time figuring out just what exactly the changes mean.
I bore you with this for one reason: Time Warner's plan may be the wave of the future, 401(k) experts tell me, at least at large companies.
I suspect my mystification is due mostly to the ample but confusing and not-always-informative marketing materials sent to employees. I imagine corporate communications at other firms making similar changes won't be much better.
So I tried to get some basic questions answered that would benefit anyone facing a similar changeover.
What your 401(k) may soon look like
Time Warner changed its investment line-up in two ways:
First, it reduced the number of investment options from over 100 to just 17. In the past decade, the thinking in the 401(k) industry has been "the more choice, the better," said David Wray, president of the 401(k)/Profit Sharing Council of America. But now the thinking is too much choice causes deer-in-the-headlights syndrome.
The 17 funds in our plan cover the basic asset classes and investment styles to create a diversified portfolio. So if you know your desired asset allocation, it's easy to pick the funds you need.
The second change was more significant in my view. Rather than continue to offer publicly traded mutual funds, Time Warner is offering mostly separately managed accounts and commingled funds, which are not publicly traded.
That means they are open only to Time Warner employees in the case of separate accounts, or to the employees of a handful of companies, including Time Warner, in a commingled pool.
"There's clearly a trend away from retail mutual funds to more institutionally managed funds," said Harold Small, a principal of the 401(k) advisory firm FiduciaryVest.
Here's what that means to you and me in terms of:
Costs: The expense ratio you pay to invest in a fund reduces your net return: the higher your expense, the less money you make.
Institutionally managed funds tend to be much less expensive than publicly traded ones, since your employer has more leverage to negotiate fees.
Lower costs can mean we get to keep an extra few hundred dollars a year in our accounts, which, compounded over time, is not insignificant.
Performance and track record: What most concerned me about our new fund lineup was that there was no past performance data or lists of holdings for most of the new funds.
Past performance may be no guarantee of future results but it gives you an idea of how a fund performs in good times and bad.
In terms of holdings, I'd like some assurance that my money won't be too heavily invested in any one company when I look at my portfolio as a whole.
According to Small, a company would likely hire an investment firm to run a particular type of fund (e.g., small cap blend) in which they have a good track record. The holdings in that fund are likely to replicate about 90 percent of the holdings in a comparable retail fund run by the same investment firm.
So you might use information on that publicly traded version as a proxy, until your fund starts reporting performance and holdings.
Transparency: You can't look up information about non-public funds at fund trackers like Morningstar or in the press. So you are reliant on your employer and its investment service providers to give you the information you seek. Typically, performance is reported quarterly, Small said, even though fund shares are priced daily.
What should you do?
Before hiring outside investment managers, your employer has the responsibility to ensure they'd act in the best interest of plan participants, said Rick Applegate, a 401(k) adviser and certified financial planner. And your employer needs to continue monitoring the investment managers' performance once they are hired.
Despite my grousing, I'm somewhat confident Time Warner has done a reasonable job picking decent investment managers who can provide reasonable returns.
"You should spend no time whatsoever wondering if those funds are good for you, once you're confident your employer has done the proper due diligence," said Wayne Bogosian, president of the Personal Financial Education Group.
I'm influenced, too, by studies suggesting that over the long term it's less important what individual funds you invest in (save the true dogs) than that you maintain a diversified, low-cost portfolio and invest money steadily over the years.
But some of my colleagues are having none of it. They like the old plan and they don't want to give up the funds they were invested in. So they've decided to open self-directed brokerage accounts through the plan. Those accounts let them invest in a wide array of publicly traded mutual funds.
There's an account maintenance fee and the expense ratios of the funds they invest in are likely to be higher than those in the plan.
There are two reasons to opt for a brokerage account, Small said.
If you want exposure to investment strategies not available within your plan; or
If you think you can get better returns and/or less risk from funds with similar strategies to those in the plan. But the rewards have to be high enough to more than offset your additional costs to use the account.
Whether you choose to invest inside your plan or out, you first should figure out how much you can contribute and what target rate of return you'll need to achieve your long-term goals based on your contributions, Bogosian and Applegate said.
Then create a portfolio that gives you a good chance of achieving that, but which also suits your risk tolerance and time horizon.
In my case, I'm first going to dig through the marketing materials again to see if I can intuit what the heck it is I'm really getting myself into.
Improved 401(k)? Who can tell?
Fund line-ups are changing. If Time Warner's plan is any indication, the changes may be baffling.
October 5, 2005: 11:40 AM EDT
By Jeanne Sahadi, CNN/Money senior writer
NEW YORK (CNN/Money) – Which would you prefer: a restaurant that offers a select number of well-prepared entrees or a menu with listings that rival the number of words in the dictionary?
Personally, I prefer the first option. Too much choice exhausts me.
So you'd think the move made by Time Warner, my employer, to simplify and reduce my 401(k) investment choices would delight me.
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/advlinks1.gif
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_bar.gif
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/whatsthis.gif (javascript:CNN_openPopup('/services/overture/cl/frameset.exclude.html','620x430','toolbar=no,locat ion=no,directories=no,status=no,menubar=no,scrollb ars=no,resizable=no,width=620,height=430'))
Become a Certified Financial Planner (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg18tSkYK9k7PyMPiIRvydmwBay5yqoZ04T48sS 5BB5iFgUON8brWQ4rF1Se9g6g7Uz%5FOS%5FLFUVYf27o3%5FE Aj8TVSPG%2Db924Wwy51vb%5FshbOFg9Otvy%2Dvqn45JPXwBZ G24b5Hrz6yfeK%2DNMn8694Z1zGnq%2DvVtt82wwObqI4m8gQ8 t9lyEEaQF7aZagsvHKO8NSKQWDNSYhXrSRqwbvdt145uiKGJRJ Sir4mYEvB75ZDNy8%5FGZNZla6OuuxM6VOra%5F2IAIMhHH5KI 6tk%5FImifMlZojaivc1%2DYbhh19K6b9YCTalgIttq%5FYjeS dJNVlqFD%2DC4iHQjP6MhwlExguDPavaReXcTB1jUrOLfoVNYH q7GHvXuqLDDZlMxQMquL0KPQ%2D0TiVn3g1XiKVRrTniA%2E%2 E&yargs=info1.cffp.edu)
Founded in 1972, the college for financial planning created the Certified...
info1.cffp.edu (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg18tSkYK9k7PyMPiIRvydmwBay5yqoZ04T48sS 5BB5iFgUON8brWQ4rF1Se9g6g7Uz%5FOS%5FLFUVYf27o3%5FE Aj8TVSPG%2Db924Wwy51vb%5FshbOFg9Otvy%2Dvqn45JPXwBZ G24b5Hrz6yfeK%2DNMn8694Z1zGnq%2DvVtt82wwObqI4m8gQ8 t9lyEEaQF7aZagsvHKO8NSKQWDNSYhXrSRqwbvdt145uiKGJRJ Sir4mYEvB75ZDNy8%5FGZNZla6OuuxM6VOra%5F2IAIMhHH5KI 6tk%5FImifMlZojaivc1%2DYbhh19K6b9YCTalgIttq%5FYjeS dJNVlqFD%2DC4iHQjP6MhwlExguDPavaReXcTB1jUrOLfoVNYH q7GHvXuqLDDZlMxQMquL0KPQ%2D0TiVn3g1XiKVRrTniA%2E%2 E&yargs=info1.cffp.edu)
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_dotted.gif
CFP?? Certification Course Online from BU (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg139S9YK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLis%5FrsY8xUcg vRssNry9yErk7O7ydypssFLIw8UqFkLLIreNDQ6qlzK7CDE7WB VzQTfb8qN6BotpuYO%2DhWb5GkrEqgrm2ytNbPwtbOTH3O9O%2 DnOvZItC5w0x7ndxWj1nAq6g7laDgnLlPTumBiQ4XuwCFf8VRr 7Z6jMnBKYxYM8ZYftqZki6WdJVByso36ZmpO1FkKyurkWwJ3Fi CJ0J51bifJdsEuLbzmpnrMaDwndtbbESa8%5F1l7xmAiivMi9k 7YkK%2D%2DLpQ5l9wOKz4Y0zfjg4uXJ3s6KuGfNFj7gCfXM3ZE QL0ZkZ6CUFzROCaMVTIeRhI7x30ceY3cb%2D4uGCzA7iABCgxJ ipB7N7mZ5JP9V6ZkGUwSmuPi6fHr%2DJ7Ii5I4QSg2gGL%2Dk1 nifc%2D%2D%2DneK9BV%5FYyKn1WiBTEW5l3uq939BNSep1hUp WRptqRfVrkP37c98mwL73nPh62RqtoZo4QQb76dhzY9x5%2DDJ QB3MOeOa7V%5FLrc%2E&yargs=www.bostonifi.com)
Pass the CFP?? certification exam - enroll in Boston University online program...
www.bostonifi.com (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg139S9YK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLis%5FrsY8xUcg vRssNry9yErk7O7ydypssFLIw8UqFkLLIreNDQ6qlzK7CDE7WB VzQTfb8qN6BotpuYO%2DhWb5GkrEqgrm2ytNbPwtbOTH3O9O%2 DnOvZItC5w0x7ndxWj1nAq6g7laDgnLlPTumBiQ4XuwCFf8VRr 7Z6jMnBKYxYM8ZYftqZki6WdJVByso36ZmpO1FkKyurkWwJ3Fi CJ0J51bifJdsEuLbzmpnrMaDwndtbbESa8%5F1l7xmAiivMi9k 7YkK%2D%2DLpQ5l9wOKz4Y0zfjg4uXJ3s6KuGfNFj7gCfXM3ZE QL0ZkZ6CUFzROCaMVTIeRhI7x30ceY3cb%2D4uGCzA7iABCgxJ ipB7N7mZ5JP9V6ZkGUwSmuPi6fHr%2DJ7Ii5I4QSg2gGL%2Dk1 nifc%2D%2D%2DneK9BV%5FYyKn1WiBTEW5l3uq939BNSep1hUp WRptqRfVrkP37c98mwL73nPh62RqtoZo4QQb76dhzY9x5%2DDJ QB3MOeOa7V%5FLrc%2E&yargs=www.bostonifi.com)
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_dotted.gif
Financial Advisors: Acquire New Clients (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg19hS4IK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLitrtsZ4sXsU%5 FRpYBsmw%2DDr1gYfCez5BtTpg4vxiDwPeV%5FLFHVYf2mfyNF w2JQVSJEfW9pfjJzvk%2DNa2gKNBOgLZYwe3s75AcZSu6V16CC or9k%2D%5FIJNX9PHZP%2DYsVjkjIv6I2jfiKtO4XZrusq1V8% 2DCrWJ54FGZMa5ZWefJcJGoJqftmf4CWRdJ01z95j056pPzZOY BeSv2gLrFyEJSY94qPOdYkAsaO148%2DbZLGiyJBIOBXNq6oi5 U3DizrEn9M2YmrU0O0Izg1dGvfsIGaM1lV66ric9ZLWKNx9uS6 mS9LYEHDhJ094flMRA%2DGtYgCcKDJivHHaLMsTN5zss3fvSd7 SRH5IMRdJq8X2aZhd7g7ejGspBiOpBoXlgB18b7Mtik%2DnrmG ny30%2E&yargs=www.wiseradvisor.com)
(U.S. only.) WiserAdvisor.com lead generation service, for retirement/estate...
www.wiseradvisor.com (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg19hS4IK9k7PyMPiIRvydhRlLitrtsZ4sXsU%5 FRpYBsmw%2DDr1gYfCez5BtTpg4vxiDwPeV%5FLFHVYf2mfyNF w2JQVSJEfW9pfjJzvk%2DNa2gKNBOgLZYwe3s75AcZSu6V16CC or9k%2D%5FIJNX9PHZP%2DYsVjkjIv6I2jfiKtO4XZrusq1V8% 2DCrWJ54FGZMa5ZWefJcJGoJqftmf4CWRdJ01z95j056pPzZOY BeSv2gLrFyEJSY94qPOdYkAsaO148%2DbZLGiyJBIOBXNq6oi5 U3DizrEn9M2YmrU0O0Izg1dGvfsIGaM1lV66ric9ZLWKNx9uS6 mS9LYEHDhJ094flMRA%2DGtYgCcKDJivHHaLMsTN5zss3fvSd7 SRH5IMRdJq8X2aZhd7g7ejGspBiOpBoXlgB18b7Mtik%2DnrmG ny30%2E&yargs=www.wiseradvisor.com)
http://i.a.cnn.net/money/images/contextual/cl_dotted.gif
Kiplinger Wealth Management Directory (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg1wtSiIK9k7PyMPiIRvydmQdMyMTqpZ4sEcUgX YANtC0vGL1hPfychMobGK4ht12FtKaB%5F9MSLfL5jfmMRlH1E BrORqGn7ry7icl4Y7qjX5IYwvF%5Fk%5F%5Fq6tkIaT1CJyzkb 4Gzne%5FMNoeAS3NM%5F4sGxRue9fJu143PsepvYsuq3yB6jy% 5FSIplymdQtl56afZcMSrJDDIHanieScZxFzdV9leilKGNHeWn xvBs6kVvxLTkJoNq%2De4sKz7f3jduoWoekwYxTaxSjxEVi6Bj lynmZyP9nNGzB%2Dr5YhgJ9P6aKZDnYiwxavuycgfHSL9VrqHT WCc%5FURS6jKFQoLRsuDOLkbwCcYThqu0vTY8MfL5jwqXrvXKH GUXF5PAZD%2DZDNWMsH4xPP0DNsFWefR4ORtSxLJII%2Dk1699 iOLqBMn4bRop6KZeZMK79DK9heLChwB%5FEDosMzyBODO%5FBB DsnYmusFOD%2DRjpNwP8GoY%5FiuA1tL6lw%2E%2E&yargs=ki plinger.directorym.com)
Evaluate and contact respected wealth management certified financial planners,...
kiplinger.directorym.com (http://www22.overture.com/d/sr/?xargs=15KPjg1wtSiIK9k7PyMPiIRvydmQdMyMTqpZ4sEcUgX YANtC0vGL1hPfychMobGK4ht12FtKaB%5F9MSLfL5jfmMRlH1E BrORqGn7ry7icl4Y7qjX5IYwvF%5Fk%5F%5Fq6tkIaT1CJyzkb 4Gzne%5FMNoeAS3NM%5F4sGxRue9fJu143PsepvYsuq3yB6jy% 5FSIplymdQtl56afZcMSrJDDIHanieScZxFzdV9leilKGNHeWn xvBs6kVvxLTkJoNq%2De4sKz7f3jduoWoekwYxTaxSjxEVi6Bj lynmZyP9nNGzB%2Dr5YhgJ9P6aKZDnYiwxavuycgfHSL9VrqHT WCc%5FURS6jKFQoLRsuDOLkbwCcYThqu0vTY8MfL5jwqXrvXKH GUXF5PAZD%2DZDNWMsH4xPP0DNsFWefR4ORtSxLJII%2Dk1699 iOLqBMn4bRop6KZeZMK79DK9heLChwB%5FEDosMzyBODO%5FBB DsnYmusFOD%2DRjpNwP8GoY%5FiuA1tL6lw%2E%2E&yargs=ki plinger.directorym.com)
if(cnnEnableCL){if(location.hostname.indexOf('.cnn .com')==-1){cnnAddCSI('contextualLinks','/.element/ssi/contextual/story.html','origin=money&site=cnn_moneveryday_dyn_ctxt&category=moneyeveryday&url=http://robots.cnnfn.com/2005/10/05/commentary/everyday/sahadi/index.htm');}else{cnnAddCSI('contextualLinks','htt p://cl.cnn.com/ctxtlink/jsp/money-story.jsp','origin=money&site=cnn_moneveryday_dyn_ctxt&category=moneyeveryday&url=http://robots.cnnfn.com/2005/10/05/commentary/everyday/sahadi/index.htm');}}
It might, except I've had the hardest time figuring out just what exactly the changes mean.
I bore you with this for one reason: Time Warner's plan may be the wave of the future, 401(k) experts tell me, at least at large companies.
I suspect my mystification is due mostly to the ample but confusing and not-always-informative marketing materials sent to employees. I imagine corporate communications at other firms making similar changes won't be much better.
So I tried to get some basic questions answered that would benefit anyone facing a similar changeover.
What your 401(k) may soon look like
Time Warner changed its investment line-up in two ways:
First, it reduced the number of investment options from over 100 to just 17. In the past decade, the thinking in the 401(k) industry has been "the more choice, the better," said David Wray, president of the 401(k)/Profit Sharing Council of America. But now the thinking is too much choice causes deer-in-the-headlights syndrome.
The 17 funds in our plan cover the basic asset classes and investment styles to create a diversified portfolio. So if you know your desired asset allocation, it's easy to pick the funds you need.
The second change was more significant in my view. Rather than continue to offer publicly traded mutual funds, Time Warner is offering mostly separately managed accounts and commingled funds, which are not publicly traded.
That means they are open only to Time Warner employees in the case of separate accounts, or to the employees of a handful of companies, including Time Warner, in a commingled pool.
"There's clearly a trend away from retail mutual funds to more institutionally managed funds," said Harold Small, a principal of the 401(k) advisory firm FiduciaryVest.
Here's what that means to you and me in terms of:
Costs: The expense ratio you pay to invest in a fund reduces your net return: the higher your expense, the less money you make.
Institutionally managed funds tend to be much less expensive than publicly traded ones, since your employer has more leverage to negotiate fees.
Lower costs can mean we get to keep an extra few hundred dollars a year in our accounts, which, compounded over time, is not insignificant.
Performance and track record: What most concerned me about our new fund lineup was that there was no past performance data or lists of holdings for most of the new funds.
Past performance may be no guarantee of future results but it gives you an idea of how a fund performs in good times and bad.
In terms of holdings, I'd like some assurance that my money won't be too heavily invested in any one company when I look at my portfolio as a whole.
According to Small, a company would likely hire an investment firm to run a particular type of fund (e.g., small cap blend) in which they have a good track record. The holdings in that fund are likely to replicate about 90 percent of the holdings in a comparable retail fund run by the same investment firm.
So you might use information on that publicly traded version as a proxy, until your fund starts reporting performance and holdings.
Transparency: You can't look up information about non-public funds at fund trackers like Morningstar or in the press. So you are reliant on your employer and its investment service providers to give you the information you seek. Typically, performance is reported quarterly, Small said, even though fund shares are priced daily.
What should you do?
Before hiring outside investment managers, your employer has the responsibility to ensure they'd act in the best interest of plan participants, said Rick Applegate, a 401(k) adviser and certified financial planner. And your employer needs to continue monitoring the investment managers' performance once they are hired.
Despite my grousing, I'm somewhat confident Time Warner has done a reasonable job picking decent investment managers who can provide reasonable returns.
"You should spend no time whatsoever wondering if those funds are good for you, once you're confident your employer has done the proper due diligence," said Wayne Bogosian, president of the Personal Financial Education Group.
I'm influenced, too, by studies suggesting that over the long term it's less important what individual funds you invest in (save the true dogs) than that you maintain a diversified, low-cost portfolio and invest money steadily over the years.
But some of my colleagues are having none of it. They like the old plan and they don't want to give up the funds they were invested in. So they've decided to open self-directed brokerage accounts through the plan. Those accounts let them invest in a wide array of publicly traded mutual funds.
There's an account maintenance fee and the expense ratios of the funds they invest in are likely to be higher than those in the plan.
There are two reasons to opt for a brokerage account, Small said.
If you want exposure to investment strategies not available within your plan; or
If you think you can get better returns and/or less risk from funds with similar strategies to those in the plan. But the rewards have to be high enough to more than offset your additional costs to use the account.
Whether you choose to invest inside your plan or out, you first should figure out how much you can contribute and what target rate of return you'll need to achieve your long-term goals based on your contributions, Bogosian and Applegate said.
Then create a portfolio that gives you a good chance of achieving that, but which also suits your risk tolerance and time horizon.
In my case, I'm first going to dig through the marketing materials again to see if I can intuit what the heck it is I'm really getting myself into.