Shouldn't the column headings read May, April. and March, rather than April, March and February?
THANKS PYRIEL for the help getting this together. Pyriel has been putting all the moves into a spreadsheet, and I've been doing the monthly totals. I would not have the time to do this tally if it were not for him.
I started keeping track of a few people I know are faithfully posting there moves. I like to see how people are doing. You should not use just this post to judge how people are doing totally because we don't have a long track record yet. As an example, someone could do very well in October but have had a very bad July/August.
May AprilMarch Last 3 Months 2005 Total
G-man3.56% 0.37% 0.37% 4.30%4.41%HighestQuarter
Systemtrader -1.38% 0.47% -0.01% -0.91%0.14%
Safetyguy2.95%-2.48% 0.37% 0.84% -0.02%
GaGal2.91% -1.88% -1.83% -0.80% -1.69%
TSPgo 1.32% -2.49% -0.81% -1.98% -1.70%
Mike 3.31% -2.52% -1.37%-0.58% -1.82%
Show-me 1.72% -1.67% -3.10% -3.04% -1.83%
TSPTalk 3.41%-3.44% -0.30% -0.33% -2.03%
Milk2 0.35% -2.62% -0.79% -3.07% -2.06%
DrD -0.01% -0.95% -1.89% -2.85% -2.37%
Pyriel 3.62% -6.06% -0.94% -3.37% -3.52%
Rod 1.07% -4.61% -1.07% -4.60% -3.71%
coolhand 0.96% -1.92% -0.27% -1.22% -4.34%
Neirbod-0.40% -2.27% -1.78% -4.45% -5.39%
TennisGuy 4.61% -1.88% #N/A #N/A #N/A Highest April
Citizen 4.31% -2.91% 0.79%2.19% #N/A
CSI 3.84% #N/A #N/A #N/A #N/A
Namor 3.41%-2.83% -3.14% -2.56% *Couldn't post part of Jan.
Tekno 2.39% -2.40% 0.66% 0.65% #N/A
Nnuut 2.36% -3.40% #N/A#N/A #N/A
Skip 2.35% -3.56% 0.28% -0.93% #N/A
cowboy 2.20% -1.10%-0.54% 0.56% #N/A
gritz 1.02% -2.43% #N/A#N/A #N/A
F-fund 1.05% 1.35% -0.48% 1.92% 1.92%
G-fund0.37% 0.37% 0.37% 1.11% 1.86%
20% Each Fund 2.04%-1.23% -1.24% -0.43% -0.12%
C-fund 3.15% -1.90% -1.71% -0.46% -0.80%
S-fund 6.05% -3.72% -1.86% 0.47%-0.89%
I-fund -0.40% -2.27% -2.52% -5.19% -2.71%
I got these numbers using the post from each account talk list (2 exceptions - Milk-man was e-mailing me his moves during a 'vacation' and tspgo has a website where he posts his moves). If you are a regular poster but I missed you it was because I either felt you were not posting regularly, posting moves too late after deadline, thought you had quit or you were not posting in the right place. I did not get to check for any new additions to the list this month and only CSI got added because Pyriel had his data. Next month I'll have more time.
Since there are so many people posting, I'm not going to add you up if your post are too confusing or it looks like you missed some post (ie. you refer to a move that you made 3 days ago but did not post in your account). I'll catch you next month when you get it straight.
You'll notice a couple new changes. I added a total for 2005 column, added each of the funds as well as the 20% each fund, and have ranked the participants based on annual total so far.
Extras:
Spaf: Thanks for starting an account.
Rolo, it looks like the magic 8-ball has quit working.
If I missed you and you weren't included, PM me and I'll add you to the list or let you know where you confused me. There are so many new faces that it would be easy for someone to fall through the cracks.
A distribution of monkeys throwing darts to choose their allocations would likely have produced a higher performer ...-Desperado ...My Account
& My Account Talk
Shouldn't the column headings read May, April. and March, rather than April, March and February?
Once again Fundsurfer and Pyriel- You're both >
For both of you >
PS Pyriel,That's not just another guy; it's the delivery boy.
Thanks EWguy, I was able to edit the post. You were correct.
A distribution of monkeys throwing darts to choose their allocations would likely have produced a higher performer ...-Desperado ...My Account
& My Account Talk
Thanx for the effort!
BTW, "My Return Year" , as reflected on my TSP spreadsheet that Tom created is:
-1.56
That is quite a difference from the 2005 total of -3.71you have reflected.
IMO, our Return Year is a better representation of how we are truly doing.
Maybe you should request that from each of us next time?
Just a suggestion so the figures are not misleading as to how we are performing.
God Bless
"You rise. You fall. You're down then you rise again. What don't kill ya make ya more strong."
- Metallica
Thanks FundSurfer, really appreciate your time and effort. I was hoping April turned around, only wish it was larger %, but the strategy for now is hit and run and only conservatively until things clear up (also helps that I finally figured out the "lock in" procedure with TSP :shock.
Again, nice job :^.
Regards,
Mike
Great job.
Know that is a lot of work.
Gives ya a good idea who to share with ideas with and who to avoid.
Not to be negative but everything you learn can be utilized for investing and your financial future.
Find folks that beat the indexes and interact with them.
Even if you have to PM to avoid the bashers.![]()
Thanks for your hard work. It's really appreciated.
Also I extend my appreciation and gratitude to Pyriel for his contribution to this board and to Tom for making this magnificent tool available to all of us.
TSPGO!
For charts visit www.tspgo.com
Lets see here G man sells G makes +.11 a share buys S on 5/9 and sells on 5/17 losses .09 a share and at the end of the month gains +.14 a share and you have him gaining 3.56% for the month of May. Mmmmm? what am I missing here? It must be the setting in G in April that netted him the gain or what?
Rod wrote:Hmmm... I could have sworn I checked you twice. Will relook at your tracker again...Thanx for the effort!
BTW, "My Return Year" , as reflected on my TSP spreadsheet that Tom created is:
-1.56
That is quite a difference from the 2005 total of -3.71you have reflected.
IMO, our Return Year is a better representation of how we are truly doing.
Maybe you should request that from each of us next time?
Just a suggestion so the figures are not misleading as to how we are performing.
God Bless![]()
I have no idea how I got the highest for the month. Must have been beginners luck i guess. I wish I had more money in my tsp so i could actually see a big difference in my total. I have been listening to Tom, Mike, Rod, and Pyriel for guidance and make a decision from them. But this in only one month so don’t follow me!
Tennisguy
|
S&P 500 (C fund) 1d 5d 3m 6m 1y 2y | Dow Completion (S fund)
| EFA (I fund) 1d 5d 3m 6m 1y 2y | Bonds (F fund)
|
Bookmarks