View RSS Feed

TSP Talk Blog

Surprise!

Rate this Entry

2/17/12

Just when we thought the market was about to start to pullback, we get a big rally triggered by another better than expected weekly employment report. The Dow gained 123-points and we saw new multi-month highs on many indices. Is this a sucker rally before the pullback?


For the TSP, the C-fund was up 1.12% yesterday, the S-fund gained 1.71%, the I-fund added 0.57%, and the F-fund (bonds) fell 0.35%.

The S&P 500 closed at its highest level since last May. The rising support line held and the rising trading channel, which is looking more like a rising wedge, is narrowing as it approaches the 2011 highs.


Chart provided courtesy of www.decisionpoint.com, analysis by TSP Talk

We had talked about whether we could see a double top on the S&P at the 2011 highs, but then we looked at the Nasdaq 100 chart, one of leaders, and it has already blasted off to new highs. That could make it less likely that the S&P 500 would create a double top, but The Nasdaq 100 is greatly influenced by Apple, and its stock price has gone parabolic in the last 3 months so it may not be a great comparison.


Chart provided courtesy of www.decisionpoint.com, analysis by TSP Talk


The Dow Transportation Index, which had broken down from its rising trend and became a concern for the market, rebounded strongly off of the 50-day EMA on Thursday, but it is still below the 20-day EMA so this could be just a temporary relief rally that could have trouble getting back above resistance. I think we will find out soon enough.


Chart provided courtesy of www.decisionpoint.com, analysis by TSP Talk


The price of oil is back over $100 a barrel and while the rising price of oil could indicate a higher demand because of the improvement in the economy, we could also start to see it be a burden on consumers because when it remains above $100, it pushes the price of gas closer to $4 a gallon. That's not good for anyone except oil companies, their share holders, a bullish oil traders.


Chart provided courtesy of www.decisionpoint.com, analysis by TSP Talk

I am temped to say that yesterday's stock market rally was a sucker rally - a last push higher to suck in more buyers, just in time for a correction - but our Sentiment Survey is again telling us that investors (at least those here on TSP Talk) are still too bearish.

The Survey came in at 47% bulls, 43% bears, for a bulls to bears ratio of 1.09 to 1. That is another buy signal in a bull market which means the system will remain 100% S Fund for next week and I continue to believe is one of the reason that this rally refuses to die. Too many people are expecting it to. For my sake, and for the sake of the many bearish leaning TSP Talk survey takers, I hope they are right.

By the way, the sentiment systemis already up 11.6% in 2012. How many of you gave up on it last year? After a great 2010, which gave it a big following, it fell off in 2011. That's how these systems seem to work. They do their best after the most people give up on it. And the more that people jump on board when it is doing well, the worse it does. Why? I wish I knew.

Thanks for reading! Have a great holiday weekend!

Tom Crowley



The legal stuff: This information is for educational purposes only! This is not advice or a recommendation. We do not give investment advice. Do not act on this data. Do not buy, sell or trade the funds mentioned herein based on this information. We may trade these funds differently than discussed above. We use additional methods and strategies to determine fund positions.

Submit "Surprise!" to Digg Submit "Surprise!" to del.icio.us Submit "Surprise!" to StumbleUpon Submit "Surprise!" to Google

Comments

  1. Cactus's Avatar
    That's how these systems seem to work. They do their best after the most people give up on it. And the more that people jump on board when it is doing well, the worse it does. Why? I wish I knew.
    So, it only works when I don't use it and when I do it goes in the toilet. Not too useful then. You'd be better off using my moves as a contrarian indicator. I've been 100% G since 12/30/11 and it looks like I'm going to stay there awhile.
  2. tsptalk's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Cactus
    So, it only works when I don't use it and when I do it goes in the toilet. Not too useful then.
    Not you, in particular, but "the herd". Those who stick it out will be rewarded. The system is up 127% since 2006 while the best TSP fun are up 43% (C) and 44% (F).

    The problem is, people stop following it when it has a bad stretch.

    By the way, this is true of most systems. People can't follow them - no discipline, so they usually do worse than the system. Myself included.

    People have been cancelling their Trader Fred subscription this year because he's missed the rally, yet he has the best long term record of all the services (pre I_T). They'll probably jump back in AFTER he has a good run.
  3. murph's Avatar
    Did you start the Sentiment Survey in 2006 or are you cherry picking? (i ask because those cherries look really sweet.)

    I don't think this was your main point, but I thought you were onto something with the light crude and S&P comparison, but upon closer look, they have moved in tandem at least 70% of the time. Only recently (2012) did the decoupling have a significant impact. I don't see any actionable warning sign from comparing these two graphs. Those red vertical lines look like "you should have bailed here." Hm, I thought I saw an edge but it turned into illusion; why do I have the feeling I've been here before?
  4. tsptalk's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by murph
    Did you start the Sentiment Survey in 2006 or are you cherry picking? (i ask because those cherries look really sweet.)
    The survey started in mid-2005 and I started the system in 2006. Here's one of the oldest archived pages I could find..

    TSP - Thrift Savings Plan Talk

    The system was tweaked in 2008 when I noticed how bull and bear markets saw didfferent ranges of bullish and bearish ratios.

    I based this off of following the other major surveys (like AAII) seeing if we could take advantage of the extremes with some strict rules.

    As far as oil goes, it's the chicken and the egg scenario. Higher oil prices hurt consumer spending, which hurts the economy. When the economy weakens demand for oil goes down, and prices come down. So there is a correlation, but at some point oil gets high enough to cause consumers to spend less and eventual drive less at some point. Look for that again this spring / summer and we'll how the economy and stock market react.

S&P500 (C Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)
DWCPF (S Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)
EFA (I Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)
BND (F Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)

Yahoo Finance Realtime TSP Fund Tracking Index Quotes