View RSS Feed

Coolhand's Market Analysis

Time to Buy?

Rate this Entry
Tracking and assessing the Seven Sentinels performance on the tracker is not going to be as easy as thought it was going to be. My original thought was that I was going to trade strictly on the Seven Sentinels signals. But the whipsaw trading action we've had is forcing more interpretation of the signal than I expected. And it's skewing the performance numbers.

The SS gave a buy signal early on in this latest leg higher. But the typical internal set-up one would expect to see leading up to a buy signal was not there. This forced an interpretation of the signal rather than blind faith.

It was only a few months ago that a buy signal was whipsawed within a few days of the signal and the market promptly dropped hard and a SS sell signal was flashed.

This generally does not happen to this Intermediate Term market timing system. But a closer look at the buy signal revealed weak internals, which weren't noticed until the sell signal occurred a few days later.

And it seemed it was happening again the week before last. But this time the results were different, with the market taking off and not really looking back. Had I bought the market with both hands on that buy signal I would be up another 7% right now. Instead, the tracker will only show a modest gain due to a false interpretation of the signal.

The only thing one has to realize here is that no system is perfect and misinterpretations can and will occur. Hopefully, if it's a good system, this will not happen often. The SS has proven to be a very robust system, so I have complete faith that I'll be more successful than not.

So is it time to buy?

The very short term answer is probably yes. I am looking for weakness early this week, followed by some intense buying as all the folks who missed the run jump on the Dow bull market signal and the false H&S breakout. Volatility will almost certainly be with us in the near term.

So I am looking to buy weakness. BUT, if this plays out the way I'm expecting, I'll be selling into the next upward move, which may not last too long as this overbought condition builds and more bulls jump in. I say this because we have two new trades coming next week, which gives me a little more wiggle room this week.

Longer term, we should be looking higher. The SS is still on a buy and I won't hold cash too long. Sentiment will be key. As more bulls are minted the odds of a reversal will increase. How long and how deep that reversal might be is not clear. If the SS stays on a buy with the anticipated volatility, I'll have to be careful not to get too cute, in which case depending on how things unfold I may decide to ride it out till the next SS sell signal (which is actually my preferred strategy).

I'm making a lot of assumptions here, but they are realistic assumptions. As market conditions change I'll make adjustments accordingly.

Submit "Time to Buy?" to Digg Submit "Time to Buy?" to del.icio.us Submit "Time to Buy?" to StumbleUpon Submit "Time to Buy?" to Google

Categories
Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Boghie's Avatar
    CoolHand,

    If you use a system like SS you have to marshall your BUYs for the IFT trades. You have only two IFTs to make forward trades.

    However, you have as many bailout trades to G as you wish.

    Thus, since SS is an intermediate system I think one should follow it cleanly - without sleuthing it.

    The only problem would be a situation where it tells you to buy on August 5th, sell on August 12th - and then you are stuck. You only have retreat trades available if it switches to a buy on August 25th. By definition a mid-term system should not whipsaw like that. I would be willing to sit out some gain in a Buy/Sell/Buy whipsaw. I wouldn't want to miss the Sell in this market.

    I hate these IFT limitations.
  2. coolhand's Avatar
    For the most part, I agree with you Boghie. I'm just trying to plan for the anticipated, but react with reality. I have one IFT left this month so if we see weakness this week, I'm a buyer. And if we rocket back up again before Friday, I'm probably a seller. Then next week I'll be looking to buy again and follow the IT signal.

    It's just speculation right now. For the most part I'm waiting to buy the IT trade, but we could be in for a good downward move if things get too overbought or overbullish. If I can mitigate a hard drop lower without hurting my IT buy signal, I'll try to go for it. But it really has to be a good set-up. Otherwise, I'll ride it out.

    Quote Originally Posted by Boghie
    CoolHand,

    If you use a system like SS you have to marshall your BUYs for the IFT trades. You have only two IFTs to make forward trades.

    However, you have as many bailout trades to G as you wish.

    Thus, since SS is an intermediate system I think one should follow it cleanly - without sleuthing it.

    The only problem would be a situation where it tells you to buy on August 5th, sell on August 12th - and then you are stuck. You only have retreat trades available if it switches to a buy on August 25th. By definition a mid-term system should not whipsaw like that. I would be willing to sit out some gain in a Buy/Sell/Buy whipsaw. I wouldn't want to miss the Sell in this market.

    I hate these IFT limitations.
  3. anthony's Avatar
    Here's a thought Coolhand, or at least a thought wrapped up in a question.

    So many of our trackers and systems or just individual approaches can be classified into long and short term approaches, or slow/non-aggressive and fast/aggressive approaches, and many do both. In addition to reading individual blogs and forums, I also use TraderFred to assist in making decisions. He has trade systems that dabble in all of these categories or strategies.

    Clearly to me, a brokerage account or self-directed brokerage IRA lends itself to fast moving aggressive systems and can handle whipsaw signals. TSP and its IFT limits lends itself to a more long term and less aggressive approach.

    So the long question is, can you discern the various Seven Sentinels signals into long-term vs short-term signals, or non-aggressive vs aggressive signals?
  4. coolhand's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by anthony
    So the long question is, can you discern the various Seven Sentinels signals into long-term vs short-term signals, or non-aggressive vs aggressive signals?
    Not in any meaningful way as far as TSP is concerned. One would have to adjust the signals and do some back-testing to determine any short or long term viability. I think a long term signal might be doable, but I think a short term signal would be difficult given the signals themselves.

    If I didn't work full-time I might be inclined to play around with it, but as it stands right now, I'm happy with the results it's shown over the past 2.5 years.

    Like you though I watch other indicators, which is why I subscribe to a daily sentiment analysis service.

S&P500 (C Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)
DWCPF (S Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)
EFA (I Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)
BND (F Fund) (delayed)

(Stockcharts.com Real-time)

Yahoo Finance Realtime TSP Fund Tracking Index Quotes